MPC Hill Blast: U.S. Credit Card System is Vulnerable to Cyber Threats; Competition Would Make It Better
The latest evidence that the U.S. credit card system is vulnerable hit customers Monday, as reported by CBS News here.
The story reports:
“Customers at Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, U.S. Bank and other major financial institutions reported service outages on Monday, according to Downdetector.com.”
“Other banks seeing a spike in customer complaints about difficulty accessing their accounts include Capital One, Truist and Wells Fargo, while users also reported problems with the digital payments app Zelle, according to the outage tracker.”
“Chase also said in a social media post that a software bug in its systems affected other institutions ‘when we were party to a transaction involving other banks.’ ”
Customers of some banks had problems including:
“Accessing their online accounts”
“Viewing balances”
“Performing transactions”
“Problems with ATMs”
Problems with “online and mobile banking services”
Problems with a “mobile app”
What does this have to do with credit cards?
Well, Visa and Mastercard both require that every U.S. credit card in their systems have a single point of failure.
That single point of failure is either the Visa or Mastercard network.
Even if a bank wants to protect itself by having a backup network, Visa and Mastercard prohibit that because they don’t want the competition. The Credit Card Competition Act would end that prohibition.
And Visa and Mastercard have had repeated outages and problems of their own:
In just two years from March 2022 to June 2024, Visa and Mastercard had at least 10 combined outages.
A single point of failure isn’t the rule in some other countries. Several allow or require a second network.
U.S. debit cards all have a second network. That allows a backup if one network has an outage That backup ensures that customers continue to have access to their funds, even in the event of an outage. And having two networks on debit makes those networks compete with each other to improve security.
Once the two-network rule was finalized, debit networks (led by the Star network) quickly upgraded to encrypt every debit transaction end-to-end.
And debit networks have much lower rates of fraud than Visa/Mastercard. Unfortunately, Visa/Mastercard have about eight times the rate of fraud on a per transaction basis as other debit networks.
The evidence is clear: Having multiple networks on a card provides a backup so there is not a single point of failure — and it creates incentives for all networks to improve their security.
COMPETITION IS BETTER FOR EVERYONE
IT'S TIME TO PASS THE CREDIT CARD COMPETITION ACT
