More than 1,000 Merchants Urge Judge to Reject ‘Flawed’ Visa/Mastercard Swipe Fee Settlement

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: J. Craig Shearman
(202) 257-3678 craig@shearmancommunications.com 

WASHINGTON, Nov. 16, 2026 — The Merchants Payments Coalition today called on a federal judge to reject a proposed settlement of litigation over Visa and Mastercard credit card swipe fees after a hearing in which more than 1,000 merchants and trade associations said the proposal does not provide adequate relief.

“Businesses and associations from every state have told the court this deal provides only temporary and meager relief riddled with loopholes while giving Visa, Mastercard and the big banks sweeping immunity for their anticompetitive practices,” MPC Executive Committee member and National Association of Convenience Stores General Counsel Doug Kantor said. “Those merchants aren’t a vocal minority. They are the businesses that pay these fees every day and are forced to pass the cost on to their customers. If this flawed settlement is approved, Visa and Mastercard’s price-fixing will be protected for years to come.”

U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan, who gave preliminary approval to the settlement in June, held a hearing in New York today on final approval. The hearing came two months after 978 merchants and trade associations urged Cogan to reject the deal in an objection letter and dozens of others filed objections of their own.

“What we get from this settlement is no structural reform that creates any meaningful competition between issuers — nothing,” said Mithun Mansinghani, an attorney representing NACS and Circle K convenience stores. “An antitrust settlement that does nothing to increase that competition should be a giant red flag to this court. Competition should be the north star in any antitrust case. This settlement is way off course.”

The large number of merchants opposing the settlement is “something the court should really pause on” and ask, “Why are the merchants objecting, demanding to be let out of this deal, if it’s such a good one?” said Deborah Greenberg, an attorney who appeared on behalf of the National Retail Federation and the Retail Industry Leaders Association. “These merchants, with their general counsels supported by independent experts, evaluated this settlement and said, ‘This is not a good deal for me.’ ”

Basel Musharbash, representing a group of public interest and consumer organizations, argued that the settlement itself would amount to Visa and Mastercard price-fixing in violation of federal antitrust law.

Cogan said that if he does not approve the settlement he is unlikely to send the case back for more negotiations over another version of a settlement. 

“If I reject this, it’s going to trial,” he said, adding that a trial would be a “protracted process” of two months each of preparation time and trial days plus finding appropriate remedies if merchants win. “That’s something for me to take into account in determining whether to approve this settlement.”  

The settlement proposal comes in a 2005 class-action lawsuit alleging that Visa and Mastercard, which control 85% of the card network market, violate federal antitrust law by centrally price-fixing swipe fees charged by all banks that issue cards under their brands. An earlier settlement was overturned by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2016, and a similar proposal was rejected by Judge Margo Brodie in 2024 because it did not adequately address the price-setting structure.

The proposal does nothing to end Visa and Mastercard’s price-fixing. It would lower swipe fees only one-tenth of a percentage point — a small fraction of the 2.36% average merchants paid in 2025 — and for only five years. The reduction would apply only to interchange fees that go to card-issuing banks, leaving Visa and Mastercard free to raise the network fees they collect themselves. Merchants would be barred from suing again for at least eight years, and possibly longer.

A provision letting merchants decline rewards cards that carry above-average sweep fees would have little effect because more than 90% of card spending takes place on rewards cards, and a 1.25% cap on “standard” cards would apply to the remaining handful of cards. A provision allowing surcharges of up to 3% is unworkable under a patchwork of state laws and card network rules.

About MPC
The Merchants Payments Coalition represents retailers, supermarkets, convenience stores, gasoline stations, online merchants and others fighting for a more competitive and transparent card system that is fair to consumers and merchants. Follow MPC on Twitter, Facebook or LinkedIn for the latest on swipe fees.